Monday, 19 November 2018

Maul question

On Saturday I reffed a level 9 game. During the maul phase players went to ground, not deliberately. On two occasions players insisted they could remain holding the ball on the ground to prevent the player in possession getting the ball to scrum half ie (blue tackles red, remain on feet, maul formed. Blue and red players wrestling for ball fall to floor on red side. Blues remains holding ball preventing continuum of play). What worries me that both teams attempted this tactic and inferred this was allowed. 
I sanctioned both plays as playing the ball on floor preventing release. Was I incorrect. I have re read the Law 16.16 but I am non the wiser? 

Unfortunately the players were correct on this occasion, but well done for questioning yourself and hopefully you will be able to get it right from now on.

When a maul goes to ground legally (i.e. it was not pulled down by anyone) then players who have a hold of the ball or ball carrier do not have to release or roll away (law 16 doesn't say they have to; as it does in the tackle law for instance). 

This then becomes an unsuccessful maul because the ball has become unplayable and/or was not immediately available.  The result is a scrum turned over to the team that didn't take it in (unless it was formed from a kick in open play; see law 16.18).

The wording of the law has changed slightly in the new 2018 law book, but the law itself hasn't changed. 

Also remember they don't have to roll away if they are on the ball as it collapses, but they can't dive over the ball after the maul goes down.  And the ball must be available immediately for play to continue.

The Rugby Ref


  1. I am a new ref with just 1 season under my belt and I am confused by your response. Principle 1 of the laws states ..

    The game is played only by players who are on their feet.
    1. Players, who go to ground to gather the ball or who go to ground with the ball, must
    a. Get up with the ball; or
    b. Play (but not kick) the ball; or
    c. Release the ball.

    Cheers Rob

  2. Hi Rob
    The law you quote refers to open play rather than set pieces.
    The principle of the maul is that if you take the ball into contact in a maul situation then you have to use it, or lose it. Get the ball to the back and trundle it down the pitch. If you cant get it o the back then you are at risk of losing it. The maul is the only situation where players are not required to roll away if it all goes to ground, because if the ball is not immediately available it is turned over with a scrum.
    17. A maul ends unsuccessfully when:
    d. The ball-carrier goes to ground and the ball is not immediately available.
    The Rugby Ref